Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI)

On the assumption that the hate that has stifled public debate in recent years (if she disagrees with me she is an enemy) has now been drained from the swamp (I know, I know, I have always been a crazy optimist), let’s take a balanced look at the Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) programs Trump has tried to defund and banish.

DEI initiatives are organizational frameworks designed to promote fair treatment and full participation of all people, particularly groups that have historically been underrepresented or subject to discrimination. That sounds pretty good so the controversies must reflect the details of the approaches taken to achieve this worthy objective.

Here is an overview of the primary arguments, benefits, and challenges associated with DEI frameworks in workplaces and educational institutions produced by AI.

Pros of DEI Initiatives

  • Enhanced Innovation and Creativity: Bringing together individuals from diverse backgrounds introduces a wider variety of perspectives, experiences, and problem-solving approaches, which frequently leads to more creative ideas and robust innovation.
  • Better Decision-Making: Diverse teams are less susceptible to “groupthink.” When people with different viewpoints evaluate a problem, they tend to scrutinize assumptions more rigorously, resulting in more balanced and effective decisions.
  • Broader Talent Pools: DEI policies encourage organizations to cast a wider net when recruiting, helping them attract top-tier talent that might otherwise be overlooked through traditional or insular hiring networks.
  • Improved Employee Engagement and Retention: When employees feel valued, respected, and included, morale and job satisfaction typically increase. Higher inclusion scores often correlate with lower turnover rates and reduced recruitment costs.
  • Reflecting Customer Bases: Organizations that mirror the demographics of their customer base are often better positioned to understand, anticipate, and serve the diverse needs of their markets.

Cons and Criticisms of DEI Initiatives

  • Risk of Tokenism: Poorly executed DEI programs can sometimes reduce individuals to representatives of a specific demographic group rather than being recognized for their individual skills, merits, and achievements.
  • Potential for Polarization and Resentment: If not handled with care, poorly communicated training or initiatives can create perceived divisions or make certain groups feel alienated, inadvertently fostering resentment rather than unity.
  • Implementation Challenges and Superficial “Check-the-Box” Actions: Some organizations adopt DEI frameworks as superficial compliance measures (sometimes called “virtue signaling”) rather than enacting meaningful, structural cultural changes.
  • Debates Over Meritocracy: Critics sometimes argue that a heavy focus on demographic representation can create anxiety or tension regarding whether promotions and hiring decisions are based strictly on individual merit, qualifications, and performance.
  • Measurement Difficulties: Quantifying the direct return on investment (ROI) of cultural and behavioral training programs can be challenging, making it difficult to prove which specific initiatives are driving positive change.

Summary

Proponents view DEI as a vital framework for building fairer, more adaptable, and high-performing organizations that reflect a multicultural society. Critics, on the other hand, often focus on the implementation risks—such as superficial compliance, potential division, or concerns over fairness in merit-based evaluations—arguing that poorly designed programs can undermine their intended goals.

I see, and I think most Universities and employers see, benefits for the education of students or the atmosphere of the workplace of at least some ethnic diversity among their students or workers. But when Harvard established a higher admission standard for overachieving Chinese to make room for more underachieving Blacks the Supreme Court ruled it a violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. I value the Equal Protection Clause, and I value the diversity Harvard sought. I would not send my child to an all-white school knowing that they would be missing an important part of their education. https://wcoats.blog/2025/03/06/DEI-a-nuanced-assessment/

What to do? Part, if not all, of this problem reflects the inferior education received by many blacks, whose neighborhood public schools are often inferior to the average public school. The education of the predominantly black population of Washington, DC illustrates the problem and potential solutions. DC schools were tightly controlled by a teacher’s union that cared far more about its members’ welfare than that of the students they taught. My mother, who taught grammar school in California, detested the negative impact of the teachers’ union on education in Bakersfield.

The School Reform Act of 1995 introduced public charter schools to DC children giving brighter students an alternative to their mediocre (at best) neighborhood school. But the more dramatic reforms followed adoption of the Public Education Reform Amendment Act (PERAA) of 2007 and the appointment of Michelle Rhee as DC Public Schools Chancellor. She spearheaded aggressive, controversial reforms, including closing underperforming schools, restructuring school administration, cutting administrative staff, and introducing aggressive performance metrics. She introduced a groundbreaking teacher evaluation framework that tied teacher compensation and tenure directly to student test performance and classroom evaluations, making it easier to fire low-performing teachers and reward top talent, i.e. no more Union domination.

Nearly all 50 states now offer some form of public-school choice (such as charter schools or open-enrollment policies across school districts). Starting with Arizona in 2022, school choice programs opened to all K–12 students state-wide. Currently, 18 to 19 states have passed universal or near-universal private school choice programs. While the details vary, in principle parents can take the money given to their local public school for each of their children and apply it to any private school of their choice that meets basic statewide standards.

The School Choice (and home schooling) movement increased options for students in poor schools and has increased pressure on public schools to improve. Tracking US national average math and reading scores as measured by the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP)—often called “The Nation’s Report Card”:

Fourth grade math scores rose steadily from 213 in 1990 to 241 in 2019 (pre-covid). Fourth grade reading scores rose more modestly from 217 to 220 in 2019. By increasing the quality of education for blacks, school choice has reduced the need for universities to lower their standards for admission while still archiving the desired student body diversity.

Increasing the choices available to parents very much reflects my classically liberal beliefs.

Oren Cass and the New Right

In a recent article in the New York Times, Oren Cass presented the New Right’s case for an active role for government in our personal lives and in guiding the economy. nytimes /2026/11/11/post-trump-republicans. He contrasts his New Right views with the views of Ronald Reagan, which he misrepresents out of ignorance or dishonesty (your choice).

Contrary to Reagan’s free-trade views that markets will allocate resources to the greatest benefit of all involved, the New Right “believes that a strong manufacturing sector on these shores provides the foundation for national power, technological innovation and stable communities — so the government should use tariffs and subsidies to support an industrial base that the market, as well as foreign powers, might otherwise undermine.” Trump’s use of tariffs generally had little to do with creating a level playing field that would maximize global income. Rather they reflected his bully approach for seeking other objectives. The fact is that US manufacturing output last year was virtually the same as it was at the end of 2001 when China entered the World Trade Organization. However, employment in manufacturing has fallen because of increased labor productivity, surely a good thing. And as our economy is fully employed, the reduced manufacturing workers have found jobs elsewhere.

The Reagan administration weakened the power of labor unions with right to work laws and increased legal immigration, which created more competitive labor markets. This contributed to faster growth in national income. Per capita real income has doubled since 1980. While new green card holders grew by 524,295 in 1980, that annual rate increased to almost one million by 2004 and has remained about one million per year thereafter (except of a slight deep in 2013 and the covid years of 2020 and 2021). From the start of Reagan’s Presidency in 1981 the median real earnings of wage and salary workers sixteen years and over and employed full-time rose from $314 per week to $378 in February of this year (in 1982-4 dollars).

But Cass’s most obnoxious misrepresentation of Reagan Republicans’ views has to do with the role of virtue and its sources. Cass claims that: “The Reaganites believe strongly that liberty is the most important end unto itself. People with the liberty to make their own choices can maximize their own well-being, in this thinking, and a nation focused on protecting that liberty will enjoy the greatest freedom and prosperity as a result…  The New Right finds this absurd. Liberty cannot mean only license to do what one wants…. Between the extremes of moral relativism and oppressive conformity lies an enormous expanse in which the state can and should establish priorities, including strong families and stable communities.”

There is no way Cass is not aware of the importance Reagan Republicans put on virtue and of its development in the private sector. This is what the discussion of “fusionism” was all about. “Not all Freedom Conservatives see our project in explicitly fusionist terms, as a formal philosophical synthesis of freedom and order, liberty and virtue. But all FreeCons do believe that unless we take virtue seriously, demand it of our leaders, and transmit it to future generations, the American experiment in self-government will not be sustainable.”  Freedom Conservatism

I agree with Cass’s final statement that: “It’s easy to forget, in the day-to-day combat of partisan politics, that ideas still matter a great deal in determining who governs the nation and how. A broader battle over principles and aspirations sharpens thinking within a coalition and forces greater responsiveness to voters, who will have the final say. Their decisions, beginning with the 2028 presidential primaries, will shape the Republican Party, and with it the contours of the nation’s political debates and policy agendas, for decades to come.”  I will fight hard for the Freedom Conservatives.

Hegseth impeachment vote

Honest and good-hearted political representatives can disagree about policies for implementing the federal government’s responsibility to protect our safety and freedoms. But they have no excuse for allowing public officials to violate the rule of law—to violate the Constitution. Outgoing Rep. Thomas Massie (KY) offered articles of impeachment of the Sec of Deference Pete Hegseth for exactly such violations.

“The House voted to refer the resolution to committee, allowing Republicans to stop it from advancing during the lame-duck session. The 211-204 vote effectively punted any efforts to impeach the Pentagon chief until Democrats take back the majority.” The Hill – House Hegseth impeachment vote blocked. While all Republicans except Massie voted to send the resolution to committee, their vote succeeded “thanks largely to almost a dozen Democrats failing to show up for the early evening vote…. due to gridlock on Pennsylvania Ave., caused by a traffic accident.” 

In the recent midterm elections, the voters severely punished the Republicans for Trump’s lawless corruption. Impeaching Hegseth was an opportunity for Republicans to demonstrate that they got the message. Sadly, they chose the ignore Hegseth’s lawlessness.

“At his press conference on Monday, Massie stressed that he wasn’t seeking Hegseth’s impeachment because he was bad at his job, but because he is operating in violation of the law, and he encouraged other lawmakers to read the eight articles.

“A lot of people are saying, ‘I think Pete Hegseth is effective. He’s good at his job, and so I don’t want to vote for these articles of impeachment.’ Well, the reality is, we’re not impeaching him for being bad at his job. In fact, he was very effective at killing schoolchildren in Iran,” Massie said, referring to the February 28 US strike on the Shajareh Tayyebeh Elementary School in Minab, southern Iran, which killed at least 156 civilians, including 120 children.

“He was very effective at extrajudicial killings [bombing speed boats in the Caribbean]. There’s no argument in these impeachment articles that he’s ineffective. The argument here is that he’s broken laws and he’s violated the Constitution,” he added. The Hill

What now?

I am a classical liberal. Our country was founded and has prospered on the proposition “that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.” We jealously guard our individual liberty. We are free to decide what we want to do and how we want to do it. This liberty is subject to two major conditions: we must live with the consequences of our choices and actions, and our actions cannot interfere with the same exercise of freedom by others. 

When in 1964, at the age of 21, I voted for the first time, I was thrilled to vote for Barry Goldwater. His “Conscience of a Conservative” more or less defined my political philosophy. Ronald Reagan’s presidency that came a few years later reflected the Republican Party I believed in and supported.

When Donald Trump changed his party registration from Democrat to Republican in Sept. 2009 and was first elected President in Nov. 2016, the Republican Party I had belonged to quickly became something quite different from the one I had always supported. President Trump, an egotistical, corrupt bully, enlarged executive power freely violating norms and laws with no pushback from the Republicans in Congress. Trump unilaterally imposed tariffs indiscriminately, joined Israel in a war against Iran (after he had earlier withdrawn from the Iran deal that was preventing it from building a bomb), helped fund and arm Israel’s genocide in Gaza, imposed 43 trade deals that gave shares of American companies to the federal government, sharply reduced legal immigration despite a labor shortage, misused the Dept. of Justice and the withholding of funds to punish “his enemies,” closed the Kennedy Center when the courts wouldn’t let him put his name on it, etc. My Republican Party no longer existed. The separation of powers that our founders had wisely put in our constitution now rested only on the courts, which fortunately were doing their jobs most of the time.  https://wcoats.blog/2026/04/20/trumps-record-so-far/

First-term Trump official Miles Taylor enumerated Trump atrocities as: “In less than two years, he’s nearly destroyed the U.S. Constitution. He ignored laws passed by Congress by the dozen… took a wrecking ball to agencies he had no legal authority to delete… purged the civil service… fired the watchdogs… remade the Justice Department into an instrument of revenge… ordered the prosecution of his critics by name… thumbed his nose at the courts… put troops on the streets… sent masked agents to kidnap people in the night… shipped them to foreign prisons without hearings… teased the suspension of habeas corpus rights and the invocation of the Insurrection Act… sued newspapers and threatened broadcast networks… arrested journalists… extorted law firms and universities… jailed students for what they said… and tried to literally rewrite parts of the Constitution by executive order.”

What was I and the country to do? I continued to vote for libertarian candidates, of course, but a few days ago large majorities of American voters threw out the hapless Republicans, giving Democrats a majority in both Houses of Congress. Trump’s lawlessness and bullying can now more easily be stopped. I am very relieved by this development. Trump could brag no more about sweeping into office with a huge majority (he actually received only 49.8% of the popular vote for his second term).

My friend Robert Calderisi recently wrote that: “Another almost-too-saintly candidate, James Talarico, was asked whether he loved his opponent— the loathsome attorney-general of Texas impeached by his own party several years ago for corruption— and he said, ‘We are both children of God, so he is my brother, but with love comes accountability, as with a family member who wants to drive under the influence and you are obliged not to give him the keys to the car.’”

The new Congress can begin by rebuilding trust in our government. It can subpoena Trump and his officials to explain seemingly self-serving deals and disregard for the law. It can require greater transparency for government actions such as the firing of at least seventeen Inspector Generals and many top military officers all without explanation. https://wcoats.blog/2026/08/19/where-is-trump-going/

But I am a classical liberal, a traditional pre-Trump Republican. I do not like many of the policies Democrats often propose. So, it is time to shift gears and remake the case for a strong and efficient but quite limited government that will effectively defend America and my personal rights. Rather than damning our opponents as evil enemies, we must again engage them in debate over how best to establish the rules governing our interactions with our neighbors and countrymen, and fellow citizens of the world.

Standard time

I paid a lot for my Rado watch. It is the most beautiful watch I have ever seen in its simple design—quite the opposite of the Gaudy Rolex. Sadly, Rado no longer makes this model. Its only disadvantage was that it was hard to set and adjust. For some years I took it to the local watch repair shop to change its setting from standard to daylight savings time or visa versa. A few years ago, I just stop adjusting it and let it be an hour off half of the year.

The time on my watch has nothing to do with when I wake up in the morning, which is governed by the sun, so I sleep less in the summer than in the winter (like bears, I guess). I am happy to report that today my watch again matches the time on my other clocks. Why in the world can’t we get rid of this silly and annoying practice of changing the clock back and forth?

It doesn’t matter to me whether we freeze the clock on standard time or daylight saving time but the medical profession says that waking to sun light is strongly preferred. The Washington Post explains why in an article titled: “Why daylight saving time should be eliminated entirely” https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/10/31/daylight-saving-time-is-bad-your-health-here-better-option/ President Trump also supports ending the switches back and forth but choses the wrong one. “The president still wants permanent daylight saving time. His bill could force an awkward clock change this winter.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2026/11/01/trump-backed-daylight-saving-time-bill-could-create-midwinter-time-jump/

One way or the other I hope we can stop the switching.